‘Sense and Sensibility’ Review: Daisy Edgar-Jones and Esmé Creed-Miles Lead a Charming, Heartfelt Jane Austen Adaptation

'Sense and Sensibility' stars Esmé Creed-Miles and Daisy Edgar-Jones | Universal Pictures
‘Sense and Sensibility’ stars Esmé Creed-Miles and Daisy Edgar-Jones | Universal Pictures

It is always exciting when a new adaptation of a literary classic is announced, but whether it will do justice to the novel is another question entirely. And this film does just that.

Georgia Oakley’s reimagining of Sense and Sensibility is refreshing, carving out its own distinct identity while distinguishing itself from Ang Lee’s beloved 1995 adaptation. It is heartwarming, a bit cheeky and full of emotion, pulling viewers into the quiet yet chaotic world of the Dashwood family. The film revolves around Dashwood sisters Elinor (played by Daisy Edgar-Jones) and Marianne (played by Esmé Creed-Miles) as they navigate the loss of their father, being displaced from their family home and various complicated romantic entanglements.

The casting of Edgar-Jones and Creed-Miles as sisters Elinor and Marianne is just perfect. Edgar-Jones not only embodies the responsible older sister but also provides glimpses into her suppressed emotional pain that you can’t help but empathise with. Meanwhile, Creed-Miles delivers an amazingly raw performance as the wild and impulsive Marianne, taking you along on her journey of love and heartbreak. While romance is a key player, the true standout of the film is the relationship between Elinor and Marianne. Edgar-Jones and Creed-Miles have great chemistry on screen, which translates wonderfully into a close bond between siblings.

George MacKay instantly won me over as Elinor’s love interest, the awkward but tender-hearted Edward Ferrars. Their romantic tension and yearning for one another practically jump off the screen. Frank Dillane plays Marianne’s love interest Willoughby, channelling the character’s cowardly and shallow nature well. Fiona Shaw’s performance as the playful and sassy Mrs Jennings is a joy to watch, and the dance scenes bring a welcome sense of energy and fun to the film.

In terms of filmmaking and production, Oakley’s intentionally muted choices give the film a naturalistic feel. The atmospheric lighting in particular creates an intimate environment for emotional scenes. One particularly striking aspect of the film is the strong presence of nature, so much so that it almost becomes a character of its own. The rugged, overcast landscapes paint a simultaneously romantic and dramatic picture that seems to mirror the rollercoaster of emotions experienced by the sisters. The earthy-toned, romantic costumes move away from traditional bonnets, further grounding the characters in the world Oakley has created. Roger Goula’s string-based score adds a richness to the film that carries you along on the journey with the characters.

Bodhi Rae Breathnach, Daisy Edgar-Jones and George MacKay in 'Sense and Sensibility' | Universal Pictures

My biggest criticism is the pacing. The film’s sombre and introspective tone sometimes works against it, with certain moments feeling unnecessarily drawn out. While the slower approach allows the characters’ emotions to breathe, it occasionally comes at the expense of momentum.

Overall, despite some pacing issues, this contemporary take on Jane Austen’s Sense and Sensibility does the novel justice. Diana Reid’s screenplay occasionally steers away from the source material, modernising the story and characters to make them more relatable to contemporary audiences. The film breathes fresh life into the adored novel and captures the essence of sisterhood.

 

FOLLOW US!

LATEST POSTS