
The Mauritanian tells the true story of Mohamedou Ould Salahi, a Mauritanian man who was detained at America’s infamous Guantánamo Bay detention camp without charge for a total of 14 years. The film is based on Mohamedou’s 2015 memoir, Guantánamo Diary.
Starring Tahar Rahim, Jodie Foster, Shailene Woodley and Benedict Cumberbatch, the film is presented, rightfully, as a critical examination and condemnation of US government policy post-September 11. Like so many anti-war films before it, it casts a very large shadow over the powers and methods granted to the military, as well as the government’s classification practices. It is, in and of itself, a potent and powerful story that ought to elicit emotion and anger from viewers, yet its delivery is something of a mess.
More on Screen Realm:
The film begins in 2001 with Salahi visiting his home to celebrate a family wedding after having spent several years living in Germany. He is met by CIA agents and asked to join them for questioning. The story then jumps to 2005, when his case is brought to the attention of Nancy Hollander (Foster), a tenacious defence lawyer with a history of civil rights activism. She takes it upon herself to defend Salahi despite the presumption of guilt surrounding him, viewing the case as a matter of principle and an opportunity to protect constitutional rights. With the assistance of Teri Duncan (Woodley), a young and impressionable lawyer, she embarks on a gruelling endeavour to take on the US government. The pair are stonewalled by an endless procession of bureaucracy and an inability to access vital classified information. Cumberbatch plays Lieutenant Colonel Stuart Couch, a military lawyer serving as the prosecutor who has personal ties to the 9/11 terrorist attacks.
The director is Kevin Macdonald, whose name comes with a certain amount of prestige, having earned accolades for films such as Touching the Void and The Last King of Scotland. He returns to the political-thriller genre, which he explored effectively in his 2009 film State of Play. However, unlike that title, The Mauritanian lacks the cinematic veneer that bonds images to the screen, resulting in a wash of beige and a distinct absence of allure.
Given the nature of the story and its reliance on testimony from Salahi, the film pinballs between time frames and jerks us between stages of his incarceration. The past is represented by a 1.33:1 aspect ratio, resembling a square box, whereas the present is signified by a broader 2.35:1 widescreen format. While the distinction between moments in time is appreciated, the constant shifting between formats ultimately serves as an irritant. Adding to the distraction are several peculiar directorial decisions, including characters occasionally making eye contact with the camera and an array of awkward camera angles that distracts from the unfolding drama. There is no denying Macdonald’s aptitude as a filmmaker, and the intentions behind these creative choices are easy to comprehend. However, because the film is a patchwork of disjointed styles and commentaries, it is hard to deny that The Mauritanian is a definite misfire.
Foster provides strong leadership with a performance that is not far removed from the stoic intelligence of her career-defining turn as Clarice Starling. With several scenes showing her inside the narrow confines of the detention centre, many viewers will cast their minds back to that seminal Oscar-winning performance. Roles like this are what she does best, and her knack for inhabiting such emotionally reserved characters qualifies her as the film’s standout asset. Rahim is also convincing as the ever-suffering detainee whose question of innocence or guilt is overshadowed by the greater issue of torture and coercion. He carefully balances the scale between good and evil and helps drive the film’s broader political condemnation of two government administrations.
Furthermore, the rest of the supporting cast are very good, with Zachary Levi (Shazam!) adding to the impressive list of players through a welcome extended cameo as an intelligence agent who serves as a sort of gatekeeper controlling the prosecution’s access to highly classified documents. Corey Johnson also appears as a high-ranking officer and superior to Cumberbatch’s character, helping create a greater sense of distrust and conspiracy within the military ranks.
Despite its important subject matter and reliable performances, The Mauritanian misses the mark thanks to bland and uninspired production design and a disjointed collection of editorial styles. It was produced by the team behind the films United 93, Green Zone and Captain Phillips, and perhaps what this film is missing, and what each of those films has, is the presence of director Paul Greengrass at the helm. I imagine he would have delivered a sucker punch of a film, as opposed to a proverbial patchwork quilt that is frayed at the seams.
















